Thursday, 15 November 2007 email and reply

To whom it may concern. To accuse of being a racist, hate and violent site is nothing short of ridiculous.

Nowhere does it condone any of the things you seem to describe it as. It actually condemns violence, racism and hate and reports on accurately sourced news items and figures. It is an invaluable source of information regarding violence perpetrated in the name of Islam across the world.

You may as well brand all of the news sources uses in the same way.

Frankly, I find your double standards contemptible.


Stephen Gash



Hello Stephen,

Thank you for your inquiry regarding the site’s categorization. is a controversial site. Many people find it informative and want access to it, while many find it offensive and want to restrict access to it. While we hear from the public at both ends of the spectrum, we do our best to remain objective, and to cover the site in our list according to its content and according to our specific category definitions. Our customers’ filtering needs are then satisfied according to their own local policies and they can override to block or allow access at their discretion.

This site was analyzed and discussed at length by our Web Analyst team. There was an overwhelming agreement about the content of this site, that it meets specific category definitions. The site has a pervasive theme to expose violent acts perpetrated by Muslim extremists and asks that other Muslims should speak out against Muslim extremism. The site does not advocate discrimination, hate, or use of violence against Islam. But the site does use shocking material to convey its message, such as violent and horrific images. The images clearly meet our Violence category definition. The political views expressed within, as public controversy attests to, is in the outer limits and therefore meets our Political Opinion/Extreme category definitions. As with any site, we will modify the category ratings as the content changes. As this site has a fairly high profile, we will likely revisit the site frequently and re-review its status in our list.

Thank you.

SmartFilter Sites

Secure Computing Corporation

1 comment:

PM said...

the reply reminds me words of Walid Shoebat...

camera are there, annocement to kill an innocent is there.... everything is next to world, but world refused to see...